• Home
  • Buy our Kindle Movie Quizzes
  • Meet Team BMAF
  • Contact BMAF
    • Website Privacy Notice
    • Cookie Policy

Barking Mad About Films

One man and his dog; both barking mad about films

Film Review: A Monster Calls, But Does It Do The Book Justice?

January 6, 2017 by Bill Leave a Comment

n/a
shares
Be First to Share ->
Share on Twitter
Share on Google+
Share on LinkedIn
+
What's This?

One of our favourite reads of last year was Patrick Ness novel ‘A Monster Calls’ from an idea by Siobhan Dowd. We discovered the book, after hearing it was to become a Movie, and knew we wanted to read before seeing it!

So does the film do the book justice, Patrick Ness had written the script and from the director of The Orphanage and The Impossible, J.A. Bayona we had very high hopes.

The cast is also excellent and the initial trailers were how we imagined the books and we are pleased to report this film is a classic and will surely be in the running for our best films of 2017.

The story remains the same as the book, Conor (Lewis MacDougall) is struggling to deal with his sick mother (Felicity Jones) who is fighting an illness in hospital, and it would appear all cures are not working.

Conor is upset over this, and the prospect of having to live with his strict grandmother (Sigourney Weaver) as his father (Toby Kebbell) is based overseas in America, and his new family just have not got the room or money to take him on.

Conner, at the height of these struggles, when it looks like his mother will lose her fight for life, he is visited by a Monster, formed from a tree by a nearby church.

The monster (voiced by Liam Neeson) will tell Conor three stories, all of which will appear to have one outcome but show another, in return for this, the Monster wants to hear Conor’s story, which is also his biggest nightmare.

Anything else would give too much away but this film is near perfection. The cast are all superb, Lewis as young Conor, and Sigourney as the grandmother in particular. Liam’s voice is excellent for the monster too.

With the book you rely on the written word to tell the story, with A Monster Calls, it’s the visuals, the telling of the Monster’s stories are told with fine water colours tying into the connection Conor has with his mother over their love of art and they are simply stunning.

The film ending gives us a new connection between mother and child that was not in the book, thanks to her art portfolio that has been left behind, although we do think we did prefer the book’s ending.

The animation of the monster is also good, but we know Trees can be done well with Animatronics, FX and CGI thanks to the likes of The Lord of the Rings and Groot from Guardians of the Galaxy.

But this is not a film for CGI like many blockbusters, this a well-told story and for us, this is an absolute must see, the standards for this year have been set incredibly high on the basis of this film. Be warned, however, its story does not really make this a kids film, so if looking for a fun family boy and a monster film, may we suggest Monster Trucks.

This film is a strong character drama and a real tear jerker so you may want to bring along some tissues as you get absorbed in this wonderful modern fable about death and loss.

5 Star review for A Monster Calls
One of our favourite reads of recent years is brought to life by Director J.A. Bayona. This emotional rollercoaster of a tale is a must see – 5 Popcorns

Have you read the book? Did you like this adaptation? We would love to hear from you

You can watch the film trailer at the film’s website here:

You can buy the book from Amazon here:

 

Never miss a BMAF blog. Receive email notifications when new posts are published by entering your email address in the subscription box on the top right-hand side of this page.

 

You can also like us on Facebook for more film news and related content www.facebook.com/barkingmadaboutfilms/

 

 

 

Share on Twitter
Share on Google+
Share on LinkedIn
+

Comments

comments

Filed Under: 5 stars, Actor, Adaptation, Animatronic, Blockbuster, Blockbuster movies, Book, Book Adaptation, Book to film, Box Office, Casting, CGI, Character Drama, Characters, Chat, Childrens, Childrens book, Choice, classics, Coming of age, Creature Feature, Debate, Decisions, Different, Director, Discussion, Drama, Favourite, Film, Film Chat, Film review, Film reviews, Film Star, Films, Five Star review, Five Stars, FX, Monster movie, Monsters, Movie Discussion, Movie Monsters, Movie Review, Movie stars, review, Sad Films, Special Effects, Supernatural, Suspense, suspense film, Tearjerker, YA movies Tagged With: 5 Star Review, 5 Stars, A Monster calls, A Monster Calls Review, Based on a book, Blockbuster, Book, Book Adaptation, Book to Film, CGI, Character Drama, Cinema, drama, Emotional Film, Fable, Felicity Jones, Film, Film Review, Five star review, five stars, Groot, Guardians of the Galaxy, J.A. Bayona, Lewis MacDougall, Liam Neeson, Lord of the Rings, Monster Trucks, Patrick Ness, Sad Film, Sad Films, Sigourney Weaver, Siobhan Dowd, Tearjerker, The Impossible, The Orphanage, Toby Kebbell

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

What Have We Been Barking Mad About Recently?

  • Our Visible Review of the Invisible Man
  • Is Bad Boys For Life A Return to Form For The Franchise?
  • Is The Rise of Skywalker A Fitting End To The Star Wars Saga?
  • The Barking Mad About Films Top 10 Films of 2019
  • 10 Films We Can’t Wait To See In 2020

Jump to a Category

Jump To a Tag

3 star review 3 Stars 3D 4 Star review 4 stars 5 Star Review 5 Stars Blockbuster Book Book Adaptation Book to Film CGI Comedy Deadpool Disney drama Film Film Blog Film Review Five star review five stars Four Star review Four Stars Franchise Ghostbusters Harry Potter Horror James Bond Jaws Jennifer Lawrence John Wick Marvel Marvel Comics Movie Blog Movie review Reboot Remake review sequel Star Wars Star Wars: The Force Awakens Three Star Review Three Stars Thriller Tim Burton

Copyright © 2023 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in