• Home
  • Buy our Kindle Movie Quizzes
  • Meet Team BMAF
  • Contact BMAF
    • Website Privacy Notice
    • Cookie Policy

Barking Mad About Films

One man and his dog; both barking mad about films

Poltergeist! Remade without the scares

January 7, 2016 by Bill Leave a Comment

n/a
shares
Be First to Share ->
Share on Twitter
Share on Google+
Share on LinkedIn
+
What's This?

One of those films that as a youngster in the Eighties that I loved was Tobe Hooper‘s Poltergeist,  produced by Stephen Spielberg. 

Now like almost every other horror film of that period, such as Friday the 13th to the Evil Dead, the film has been remade. From director Gil Kenan, who directed the family friendly CGI hit Monster House.

The film has a great cast, in particular, the always watchable Sam Rockwell, but sadly as with a lot of these remakes, you have to wonder why it is needed, the original really is a classic.

However, the film does have real promise, with scares a plenty and a creepy feeling to it, especially where the notorious clown from the poster, who scared many a UK shopper http://www.theguardian.com/media/2015/jul/15/poltergeist-posters-cleared-complaints-clown-image

However, once Madison, this film’s version of Carol Ann,  is taken to the light, the film does rapidly go downhill and becomes heavily reliant on CGI scares

It is at this point of the film, it loses all its originality and follows the 1982 screenplay almost exactly.

It is a shame as the family are all great in their roles, Rosemarie DeWitt (who I know mainly for her role as Midge in TV’s Mad Men) is great as the mother, dealing with the 3 children as well as coping with her husband, who has been made redundant from his previous job.

It is little things like this, that help the story, it explains why they were looking to move to a house relocated on a former cemetery (or so they are told, those who have seen the original, will know it has not been moved)

The story has clever little updates, a Drone andMobile phones are used to show the paranormal activity, the special effects are good, the paranormal team from the University led by Dr. Brooke, played by Jane Adams (who you may know from TV shows such as Hung and Frasier) and her team also are good.

So where does it go wrong? Sadly for me, it is the TV ghost hunter character Carrigan Burke (played by the normally excellent Jared Harris) and again, he is not awful. Its just he does not have the script or character that made Tangina (the Zelda Rubinstein portrayed character) so iconic in the original.

The attempt to rescue Madison from the light is far too rushed and not scary at all. The scenes from the original of the family stuck in the mud with the corpses are missing, and the corpses in this are more CGI ghosts and again not scary at all.

Once again, prior to Madison joining those ‘friends’ talking to her via the TV set, I found this to be a solid creepy film, balls rolling across floors; hair raised from static electricity; the tree (one thing that is just as creepy as the original’s version) and those clowns all kept you spooked so it is a real shame that it did go downhill so fast.

On its theatrical release, the film was released in 3D, it is possible that this may have added to the scares but as the home release was not available in this format I can not comment but find it unlikely.

The home release is an extended version but this is to add more to the family rather than additional frights.

The original spawned 2 sequels, I personally would be surprised if this got just one!

3 out of 5 review for Poltergeist 2015
The case for not remaking films continues, a solid start but goes downhill fast in this by the numbers CGI horror

Never miss a BMAF blog. Receive email notifications when new posts are published by entering your email address in the subscription box on the top right-hand side of this page.

 

Share on Twitter
Share on Google+
Share on LinkedIn
+

Comments

comments

Filed Under: 3-D, classics, Debate, Discussion, Eighties, Extended cut, Favourite, Film, Film review, Franchise, Halloween film, Halloween viewing, Horror, Movie Discussion, Movie Franchises, Movie Review, Reboot, remake, remakes, Sequel, Thriller Tagged With: 3D, eighties, Evil Dead, Frasier, Friday the 13th, Gil Kenan, Horror, Hung, Jane Adams, Jared Harris, Mad Men, Monster House, Poltergeist, Remake, Rosemarie DeWitt, Sam Rockwell, Stephen Spielberg, Tobe Hooper, Zelda Rubinstein

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

What Have We Been Barking Mad About Recently?

  • Our Visible Review of the Invisible Man
  • Is Bad Boys For Life A Return to Form For The Franchise?
  • Is The Rise of Skywalker A Fitting End To The Star Wars Saga?
  • The Barking Mad About Films Top 10 Films of 2019
  • 10 Films We Can’t Wait To See In 2020

Jump to a Category

Jump To a Tag

3 star review 3 Stars 3D 4 Star review 4 stars 5 Star Review 5 Stars Blockbuster Book Book Adaptation Book to Film CGI Comedy Deadpool Disney drama Film Film Blog Film Review Five star review five stars Four Star review Four Stars Franchise Ghostbusters Harry Potter Horror James Bond Jaws Jennifer Lawrence John Wick Marvel Marvel Comics Movie Blog Movie review Reboot Remake review sequel Star Wars Star Wars: The Force Awakens Three Star Review Three Stars Thriller Tim Burton

Copyright © 2023 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in